Oct. 2, 2019:
Today, Jim and I have booked a tour to the Tuscan wine areas of Montepulciano and Montalcino. It turns out it is a great day for wine tasting inside, as we had barely started our tour when it started raining. We booked this tour through Viator, and as we have largely learned on past viticultural outings booked through them, what this means is that you will get a driver who takes you to various wineries; not someone who is knowledgeable about viticulture himself.
The nice part is that they will usually pick you up at or near your residence, and that was the case here, where we arranged to meet our driver, Andrea, at the Cortona city gate nearest to our apartment. The good news is that we can drink wine without worrying about driving afterwards. The bad news is that it puts you at the mercy of an Italian driver. Although Jim has gotten fairly comfortable driving in Italy, what that means is that when someone inevitably starts tailgating us, Jim either pulls off the side or sends us through a roundabout so the obnoxious driver can drive on. As Jim likes to say, “Traveling on Italian roads: where every drive is a competition, and tailgating has nothing to do with a pre-game picnic!” In short, although Montepulciano is only about a 45-minute drive from Cortona, it felt like an eternity!
In Montepulchiano, we picked up another couple for our tour, John & Rhonda (a couple of Americans now living in North Carolina). Quickly, we seemed to find many things in common with them, or maybe it was that we all liked to drink wine. Andrea drove us first to Montalcino, where we were scheduled to taste wines at two different Brunello producers.
The story of the development of the classic wine for this area (Brunello di Montalcino) is an interesting one. About 150 years ago, a special variety of the Sangiovese grape was developed by Clemente Biondi, which was capable of aging for very long periods of time in a cask. Although a version of “Brunello” (which means little brown in Italian) had been recorded as early as the 14th Century, Clemente’s grandson, Ferruccio Biondi-Santi, released what he called the first “modern Brunello” in 1888, which had aged for over a decade in large wooden barrels. However, this grape strain really didn’t take off until after World War II. In fact, the Biondi-Santi family only formally declared four vintages of their Brunello, produced only in exceptional years. Because they were the only family producing this long-lived Sangiovese, ultimately, they have secured the patent to their grape clone, which is still known as “B.B.S. 1” (Brunello Biondi-Santi 1). Today, the Biondi-Santi family still produces exceptional wines which are easily able to age 50-75 years, and even longer.
In 1980, the Montalcino region received the first DOCG (Denominazione di Origine Controllata e Garantita) for its Brunello, which is the highest level of government classification. All DOCG wines from each producer are analyzed and tasted by government–licensed judgment panel before being bottled. Vino Nobile and Barolo were the second and third wines given DOCG status at the same time. What this means is that the product in question (here: wine) must meet the highest standards of purity and adherence to the traditional methods of production, and contain only the approved ingredients from the region. In the case of Brunello, there are about 50 distinct requirements to achieve the DOCG Brunello status, but probably the most important are that the wine must be produced 100% of Sangiovese grapes grown in the 17 mile Montalcino region with no additives whatsoever, and aged for a minimum of five years, with at least two of those in oak. The vines also cannot be irrigated. This is a challenge since Montalcino typically has the hottest and driest weather in Tuscany, with an annual rainfall of about 25 inches. Traditionally, Brunello winemasters haved aged their wines in huge casks of Slavonian oak, because it had such a neutral taste. More recently, the local winemakers have been using some French oak in the aging process, which introduces notes of vanilla to the vintages. Despite all the rules governing the strict production of Brunello wines, there are many differences in the soils and elevations in Montalcino, all of which deliver wide variations in flavor to the finished product.
Our first stop was at a vineyard we had not previously heard about; Capanna. The fact that we were not familiar with this vineyard is not a mark against them, but rather a reflection the fact that we see few of the wines produced in Italy in our local wine shops. Fortunately, we had an excellent guide for our visit, who was very knowledgeable about Brunello in general, and this vineyard‘s wines specifically. We started with a view of the vineyards, but then rushed inside to the production area when it started dumping rain. Our guide explained that “Capanna” means shed, and that it was named after the woodcutter’s sheds which were previously on the property. This is the third generation of the family making Brunello on this farm. They also make Rosso di Montalcino, Moscato, Pinot Grigio, and Merlot.
Unlike some winemakers, who start their fermentation in steel casks, Capanna starts in oak from fermentation onwards. After fermentation, the wine spends 11 months in big Croatian casks, then is moved to smaller Croatian oak casks for two more years. The wine is then finished in French oak barrels for the last 2 years.
Then we moved on to tasting in the lovely tasting room inside. Our 1st wine was a white blend called “SanGioBi”. It is a white wine made with Sangiovese grapes, which spend no time on the skins. I found it very citrusy, but quite dry and floral.
Our 2nd wine was a 2017 Rosso di Montalcino. Basically, this wine must also be made of 100% Sangiovese. Think of it as the baby Brunello which doesn’t make the jump to the major leagues. Usually, at the end of the first year post-harvest, if it lacks the qualities judged to make a good Brunello (mostly, whether it is capable of aging for long periods of time), it is shunted off to Rosso di Montalcino production, and typically bottled soon thereafter. The production of Brunello is totally dependent on the quality of the grapes, and some years, the wine malers do not make any Brunello for that year’s harvest. Nonetheless, Rosso di Montalcino is still a good wine, and is often an affordable choice for a good table wine.
This Rosso was the product of a very dry summer. The wine was just bottled 5 months. I found it very tannic, but with good black berry taste although dry. Our guide told us that it is expected to last 10-12 years, and will become much less tannic during that time.
The third wine we tasted was a 2014 Brunello, which was a hard year because they had a very wet summer. The winemakers decided that the wine should spend much less time on skins because grapes so bloated with water, and because the skins were thinner. We found this wine to be more drinkable now, as opposed to the typical Brunello, which you want to put down for at least five years following its release (making the wine at least 10 years old at the time of drinking).
The 4th wine was a 2013 Brunello which by contrast, was a very dry summer. This produced a much more tannic wine, with higher alcohol content, but the winemakers predicts that it will last longer than the 2014 vintage. Our group’s consensus was that this wine needs to nap for a few years longer, but will then be excellent.
Our 5th and final wine was a 2013 Riserva Brunello. To qualify as a Riserva, a Brunello must be at least 6 years old, and age at least three years in oak. We all agreed that the extra year of aging, and in particular, the extra year in the cask, allowing for greater oxygen exchange in the wine did wonders for this vintage!
The second visit in Montalcino was to the Solaria di Patricia Cencioni. This was an interesting choice of a second visit, as the owner and winemaker is the third generation of the same family which makes Capanna. However, she obviously has some strongly held opinions about how to make wine that differ from her family. We had the privilege of being guided on our tour by her daughter, who appeared to be a very knowledgeable young vintner in her own right. The Solaria brand has existed since 1990. The vineyard started with 3 hectares of vineyards from the original Capanna farm. Over the years, Patrizia has added to her farm and it now encompasses 10 hectares of vineyard, and 8 hectares of olive groves. This is somewhat remarkable in that after the explosion of Brunello producers following the DOCG designation, Montalcino is now closed to new farms, and you can’t buy new Brunello or Rosso vineyards. Just in time for the rains (which are disastrous to the harvest), the vineyard finished harvesting yesterday.
We moved into the very modern fermentation sheds to continue our tour. Unlike Capanna, the grapes here ferment for 20-25 days in steel vats to better control temperature during fermentation. Solaria also adds some yeast to start the fermentation process (which is apparently OK since it is a natural product, and not considered a forbidden additive).
Solaria uses different types of oak for its different types of wine. They use both Croatian and French oak barrels and casks of differing sizes. The Solaria Brunello ages 3 1/2 years in oak, instead of the minimum 2 years required. The winemaker uses all the kinds of oak and sizes for the standard Brunello. For the Brunello Riserva, Solaria uses just French oak barrels, and the wine spends a total of 4 1/2 years in oak. With that, we moved to the tasting room.
The 1st wine we tasted was their 2017 Rosso di Montalcino, which only ages in oak 1 year. Here at Solaria, they use the youngest grapes in their fields to make their Rosso, because they believe it contributes to the fresh taste one naturally associates with Rosso di Montalcino. We found this wine to have a more juicy flavor, and much lighter color. It was not tannic at all, and made a good table wine.
The second wine we had was a 2014 Brunello (from that very wet year). I thought this wine was very drinkable now, and not tannic in the least.
Our third wine was Solaria’s 2013 Brunello (from the very dry vintage year,). While it was not as tannic as Capanna, there was more chocolate and tobacco on the tongue than the 2014.
Our 4th and final wine was the 2013 Brunello Riserva. This wine was produced solely from the grapes in “Vineyard 123”, and then only the best grapes from that vineyard, in which the vines are 32 years old. This wine was aged only in French oak barrels of the medium 750 liter size. We all found this wine to be much more smooth, with its tannins restrained, and an elegant finish. Pleasantly, this wine is drinkable now.Andrea then drove us back towards Monepulciano. But first, we had a brief stop in the cute medieval town of Pienza, which is right in the hill country between these two wine regions. If you didn’t know, Pienza is the home of Pecorino cheese, and cheesemongers about in the old town; all willing to give you free samples. Jim and I had visited here before, but we walked around longer enough to buy a small pecorino with truffles, and then we dashed back to the car. No historical commentary was provided, but the rain would have made it a bust anyway.
Andrea then drove us back towards Monepulciano. But first, we had a brief stop in the cute medieval town of Pienza, which is right in the hill country between these two wine regions. If you didn’t know, Pienza is the home of Pecorino cheese, and cheesemongers abound in the old town; all willing to give you free samples. Jim and I had visited here before, but we walked around long enough to buy a small pecorino with truffles, and then we dashed back to the car. No historical commentary was provided, but the rain would have made it a bust anyway.
Finally, we ended up back in Montepulciano to taste at our third vineyard; Ercolani. Because we are in town, there was no visit to vineyards, but it’s raining buckets again anyway, The Ercolani tasting rooms combine their shop, which sells not only wine, but also quite a variety of typical products from Tuscany (many of which we will later taste), but also their cellars. We went first for a quick view of the cellars, and learned a cool fact: the thing on top of the cask where wine is slowly added as it evaporates over the aging process, was invented by Leonardo da Vinci!
The huge oak barrels contain 4000 liters of wine, and are made of Croatian oak. These casks are used over and over again because they have a very neutral effect on the wine. The Ercolani cellars are actually very interesting as they were used in both Etruscan and Roman times, as well as though the middle ages. Our guide showed us a stone bath which was used to wash sheep and card wool. But enough of the tour; let’s get on with the wine tasting!
The 1st wine we tasted was a 2015 Vino Nobile, consisting of 70% Sangiovese, and 30% other Italian wines. As the wine ages, it is moved from the large casks into smaller French oak barrels, particularly for their more prestigious wines such as those destined to become Riservas.
Our 2nd wine was a 2014 Vino Nobile Riserva, from that very wet year. It was probably our favorite wine at Ercolani, and was perfectly drinkable now. Fortunately, though, Ercolani provided us with some food paired to complement the wines we were tasting, as their wines in particular seem destined to be paired with food.
The third wine was a 2013 Riserva Vino Nobile 4 star vintage. This has been a highly rated vintage, and we were accordingly only poured a small taste (ironically served in a very big glass). It looked brownish color, and smelled of somewhat like port. Candidly, we did not think it was very good, and not characteristic of Vino Nobile at all.
The 4th wine was a 2014 Brunello, because Ercolani also raises grapes in the Montalcino area. None of us liked it as much as the Brunellos we tasted at Capanna and Solaria.
Weirdly, Ercolani reverses the normal tasting process, and has you taste the white wines at the end. The 5th wine was a white blend, consisting of Trebbiano, Malvasia, Grecchetto grapes. This wine spends no time in oak, being fermented and aged solely in stainless steel. Actually, it was a very drinkable white, and would be perfect for a hot afternoon, but it seemed silly to ship any home when we have such great whites at home in California
Our 6th wine was a Vin Santo, a fortified wine which is great with desserts. The Ercolani version is a Riserva, and quite expensive in comparison with other dessert wines, but it paired nicely with the “Pan Forte” cake from the Siena region which is studded with drink fruits and very moist.
Finally, as a special treat, we were given a taste of a 2007 Brunello Riserva, which had aged 5 years in oak because the bottle had just been opened the preceding day for evaluation. Unsurprisingly, it was the best of the Ercolani Brunellos we tasted.
Our tastings concluded, we bid a fond farewell to John and Rhonda, who were staying in Montepulciano. Then Andrea drove us home. This time the 45 minute drive thankfully seemed to go much more quickly.We wrapped up the evening at another of Cortona’s great local restaurants; this time, La Locando di Pozzo Antico. Jim and I both enjoyed their tagliolini with fresh truffles, but we were happy to head home.